toggle menu
Menu
Contact Us

What is the first thing you should do when your star performer resigns?

20th Sep 2017
Employee Engagement, Employment Law, Human Resources, Recruitment

There is no longer an expectation of a job for life with the average Briton having six different employers during their career.  It can be an upheaval in the largest of organisations, but for an SME, having your star performer resign can leave you feeling overwhelmed and concerned with the future of your organisation.

It can be difficult to process and initial reactions often include wondering if you have done something wrong, and can encourage you to doubt your own management style or even business plan.

Just remember that no-one is unique and everyone is replaceable.

Our advice for guiding you through this event:

  • Accept Their Decision

It is tempting to offer the world in exchange for them staying but do you want this to become the norm, and can you afford the price? 

If someone has told their boss they are handing in their notice and leaving, they have made up their mind and whilst they may wobble if offered a promotion/pay rise / more annual leave, it is likely they will still leave. If they do decide to stay, they will be disengaged, unmotivated and will leave at the next opportunity.

Mentally they have left the organisation, and you need to accept that.

  • Prepare Yourself

You may be feeling knocked sideways and need to have a minor panic, talk it over with a mentor, or just breathe and take stock. The other person has prepared and is ready for the conversation, and you need to have this discussion equally prepared. Ask them to keep it confidential and arrange to see them once you have gathered your thoughts. This should be as soon as possible – certainly on the same day – but will give you time to prepare.

Be clear that they will be missed but that you wish them well, and congratulate them on their new position. Stay professional, positive and encouraging.

  • Telling the Team

You want to be clear that it is your role to tell the wider team and to avoid gossip and speculation you need to do that as soon as possible. Ensure the senior team are told first, followed by communication through the hierarchy. Your communication plan needs to be relevant and appropriate to each group:

Senior Team – they will be concerned with the impact on the business, and what the contingency is for short term cover initially. There is time to discuss the long-term solution later.

Team – they will be concerned with the impact on their own workload, and maybe even their own job security and role which may need to change as a result. The communication needs to be positive.  Involve them in the plan, and ask for input.

It is important to take control of arranging a leaving card or whatever is the norm for the organisation to allow the team to see that this is not a disaster.

  • Notice Period

Ensure that your employment contract has a suitable notice period. You can always agree a shorter period should the business needs allow it, but you need time to process and plan before the star performer departs. If your star performer resigns, is five working days enough time to communicate to the organisation, get work covered and produce a contingency plan?

You may need them there for handover or it may be suitable due to client confidentiality to let the employer go on gardening leave.  Whatever your decision it must comply with their contract.

  • Exit Interview – The Time To Ask Questions

There is a difference between asking what you can offer for them to stay, and discussing what has encouraged them to make this decision. Finding out their views on how the team works, how the company operates, what has attracted them to their new role, can all add value to your future plans. An exit interview can help stop losing your next star performer!

  • It’s A Small World

Your star performer can now have a role as a raving fan if you manage their departure appropriately.  Being generous and supportive of their new venture will leave them speaking fondly of the organisation. Encourage them to leave a forwarding email so colleagues can stay in touch and say goodbye in person and wish them luck. You never know when you will come across them again –  they may become a client, or even come back to work for you again.

  • See The Positive

Now is a great time to review those job descriptions, bring in a short term consultant, change policies or procedures, review your succession planning.

If you have just had “that” conversation with your star performer and would like support on managing the next steps, we would be happy to help.  Our HR Toolkit has a wealth of support including recruitment support, exit interview structures and policies. We would love the opportunity to make a difference to your organisation and help you achieve the results you need. Call on 01473 360160 for a chat about how we can support you.

Fun, different, very special – I feel very privileged to be invited and hope the connection [is beneficial].  Food was incredible, great mixture of people.  A fabulous event to do – I think that Pure might borrow the concept!  Thank you Carole & Charlotte.

Jodie Woodrow, Pure Resourcing Solutions, on our MAD networking lunch - June 2017
All Testimonials