toggle menu
Contact Us

Giving Notice To Leave A Job is Not Always A Letter Of Resignation

22nd Oct 2018
Employee Engagement, Employment Law, Human Resources

A letter that gives one month’s notice should not automatically be interpreted as a letter of resignation, an employment appeal tribunal judgment has confirmed.

The Facts

The claimant, Mrs Levy, was employed in the Records Department by East Kent Hospital University NHS Foundation Trust (the Trust). Mrs Levy successfully applied for an internal position in the Trust’s Radiology Department, subject to pre-appointment checks.

After having been given the conditional offer, and following some form of altercation with another staff member in the Records Department, Mrs Levy handed in a letter stating “Please accept one month’s notice from the above date”.

On receiving this letter Mrs Levy’s manager wrote back to Mrs Levy, accepting the “notice of resignation” and referring to her last working day in the Records Department. Mrs Levy’s manager did not complete a staff termination form (which apply only to members of staff who are leaving the Trust’s employment) and did not deal with any other outstanding issues, such as making a payment for accrued but unused annual leave.

Following the completion of the pre-appointment checks, the offer of a position in the Radiology Department was withdrawn, prompting Mrs Levy to attempt to retract her “notice of resignation”. The Trust refused to accept the withdrawal of her notice, stating that her employment would end at the end of her notice period.

Levy subsequently brought a claim of unfair dismissal. In April 2017, the employment tribunal found in favour of the claimant because it could be shown that the notice had been taken by the Trust to be notice of Mrs Levy’s departure from the Records Department and therefore Mrs Levy had not in fact resigned.

The Trust appealed the decision to the Employment Appeals Tribunal.

The EAT Decision

The EAT agreed with the ET, holding that Mrs Levy’s letter had been ambiguous despite the use of the word “notice”. Due to the ambiguity of the letter, the ET had correctly applied an objective test by asking how the words used would have been understood by the reasonable recipient of the letter. On these particular facts, the EAT held that the ET had been entitled to find that the words used in the letter related to Mrs Levy’s position in the Records Department and not to her employment by the Trust.

Lessons to Learn

Whilst the circumstances of this case are quite unusual disputes often arise over ambiguous resignations. This case serves as a reminder to ensure clarity whenever an employee resigns or offers to give notice to resign. Employers should always seek to understand why the employee is resigning, the notice they are giving and clarify when the employment will end.

The Toolkit Tour

Take the MAD-HR Toolkit Tour

An affordable, comprehensive HR portal. Access all the latest documents you need as an employer.

Book Demo
Christopher Durand
Christopher Durand
14:28 23 Aug 18
We have used MAD-HR a number of times and I have been very impressed by their knowledge and expertise, which is invaluable for us a small and growing business. All the work they have done for us, and this includes not just contracts and handbooks etc, but also training to make us a better more thoughtful team, I regard as a sound business and personal investment. We intend to make this an on-going relationship to help us develop as a more
Aisleen Marley
Aisleen Marley
14:48 24 Oct 17
Carole immediately grasped my situation and quickly set about creating the perfect document to help drive my business forward. She has a wealth of experience that she was able to apply to my current and future business goals in order to come up with the goods! The process itself was extremely straightforward with a clear system for booking in a call with Carole, where she then talked me through my options. Thoroughly more
Rachael Martin
Rachael Martin
19:40 03 Jul 17
Carol offers outstanding support and advice to ensure you are meeting legal requirements. Her toolkit is a very worthwhile investment as it ensures your documentation is up to scratch and you have all that you need in place! Highly recommended - outstanding more
ClarkeCare Ltd
ClarkeCare Ltd
14:03 22 Jun 17
I recently attended a Suffolk Brokerage Registered managers meeting and the very lovely Charlotte from MAR HR was there to give a presentation. Charlotte was fantastic and delivered a great presentation. Her knowledge around all things HR where clearly evident and she answered some tricky questions really well, giving clear, helpful advice. I would highly recommend anyone thinking of gaining support for their business to speak to Charlotte. I know we at ClarkeCare will be engaging their services in the near future. Thank you Charlotte :-)read more
Hana Dickinson
Hana Dickinson
10:36 26 Jul 16
I love working with Carole and the team at MAD-HR. They are so knowledgeable and responsive. I feel really confident that my HR (and therefore my business) is in safe hands. We've had a few issues that we've needed help with and Carole has been right there, with great advice and useful resources (via the Online HR Toolkit) that have made my life so much easier and my blood-pressure so much lower. Thanks Carole and team. You rock!read more
Next Reviews

Brilliant service and advice from MAD-HR.   Thank you so much, you’ve made the process of taking on our first employee an absolute breeze! Highly recommended.