References of High Sickness – What should you do?

You’ve received a reference reply that that your prospective employee has had references of high sickness absence over the last 12 months. What should you do?

When you make a job offer to a prospective employee it should be conditional on the receipt of references which are satisfactory in your opinion. The law doesn’t say how many references you should or can actually obtain in relation to a prospective employee but it’s good practice to seek at least two (although some employers opt for three). Where an individual has been employed previously, their former employer should always be approached for a reference.

“Outstanding HR Advice and Support ”

“A highly effective and fully engaged HR partner that understands where we are going and is with us every step of the way in helping us to get there” Read the full review

MAD-HR Feefo Rating

Significant sickness history

But let’s suppose that, in their response to your reference request, the previous employer says your prospective employee had a significant period of long-term sickness absence during the course of their employment. This revelation would naturally concern most employers – but could you use it as grounds to withdraw a job offer that you’ve already made?

The answer to this question was confirmed by the tribunal in West v Yorkshire Ambulance Services NHS Trust 2016.

West (W), who is a nurse, had been offered a job with Yorkshire Ambulance Services NHS Trust (Y) as a helpline advisor. Having made its job offer to W, Y followed best practice procedure and approached her former employer – another NHS Trust – for a reference. It replied stating that W’s employment had “ended following an 18-month period of sickness absence”. Concerned about this information, Y contacted W advising her that its earlier job offer had now been “withdrawn” but said no more.

W – who presumably put two and two together – claimed that the withdrawal of the job offer was disability discrimination contrary to the Equality Act 2010. The tribunal was struck by the speed at which the job offer was withdrawn following receipt of the reference. As a result, it concluded the previous employer’s comment about sickness absence had caused Y to doubt W’s ability to do the job and was the only reason why the job offer was withdrawn. This decision amounted to disability discrimination.

The correct approach

Y’s unexplained knee-jerk reaction was its downfall. Instead, it should have:

• discussed the issue with W to establish if she had, or may have, a disability (the tribunal found that she did)
• taken specialist occupational health or other medical advice on her condition
• considered whether any adjustments were necessary
• implemented all reasonable adjustments.

If this is done but no reasonable adjustments are possible, or adjustments will be prohibitively expensive for the employer to implement, a job offer may be withdrawn.

If this all sounds a bit daunting, remember two key things – even without an established HR team, you can call on HR experts such as MAD-HR to help you with one-off HR support projects. There is also low cost, HR help at hand if you make the most of it.

Our Online HR Toolkit which is packed with templates, contracts, documents (over 1000) as well as guidance and employment law updates. You pay by subscription and ensure that you have all the legally up-to-date HR help you need at a click of a button with your log-in. Protect your business and take the leg work out of HR. We pride ourselves on keeping SME businesses fighting fit without significant financial burden.